| Year | Name ~ College/University | Name ~ College/University |
| Year 2018: | Ms. Tayler Person ~ Towson University | Ms. Jordan Armstrong ~ University of Pittsburgh |
| Year 2017: | Ms. Rebekah Wilford ~ Robert Morris University | Ms. Danaia Winbush ~ Carlow University |
| Year 2016: | Ms. Jacqueline Spencer ~ Howard University | Ms. Jonae' Maxey ~ University of Michigan |
| Year 2015: | Mr. Ethan Parker ~ University of Michigan | Mr. Patrick Kelly ~ Temple University |
| Year 2014: | Ms. Cierra Bryant ~ University of Maryland | Ms. Megan Boris ~ Towson University |
| Year 2013: | Ms. Michelle Helsel ~ Virginia Tech | Ms. Erica Rutledge ~ Kutztown University |
| Year 2012: | Mr. Ajibola River ~ Temple University | Mr. Frank Amabile ~ Penn State University |
| Year 2011: | Ms. Shayla Bryant ~ Hampton University | Ms. Jasmine Ellis ~ Spelman College |
| Year 2010: | Mr. Blake Koolick ~ Arizona State University | Mr. Emanuel Rosu ~ U.W. Madison |
| Year 2009: | Ms. Alyssa Dixon ~ University of North Texas | Ms. Mounica Donepudi ~ Boston University |
| Year 2008: | Mr. Samrat Sanghvi ~ University of Southern California | Ms. Brittney Rowland ~ Ohio State University |
| Year 2007: | Ms. Jocelyn Johnson ~ Savannah College | Ms. Raagini Jawa ~ Boston University |
| Year 2006: | Mr. Joseph Kripke ~ Cornell University | Mr. Andrew Deen ~ Gettysburg College |
| Year 2005: | Mr. Haein Kim ~ Haverford College | Mr. Mikael Garabedian ~ Drexel University |
| Year 2004: | Ms. Roberta Thomas ~ Penn State University | Mr. Christopher Jones ~ Penn State University |
| Year 2003: | Ms. Lauren Todd ~ University of Boston | Ms. Alecia Fields ~ Valley Forge Christian College |
| Year 2002: | Ms. Kristin Dormuth ~ University of Notre Dame | Ms. Jenne Massie ~ University of North Carolina |
| Year 2001: | Ms. Roshan Thomas ~ Kutztown University | Ms. Amanda Dean ~ Penn State University |
| Year 2000: | Ms. Tazia Dobbs ~ Kutztown University | Ms. Latifa Ellis ~ Trinity College |
